Prior Office Action responses directed by others were unsuccessful. IpHorgan dug deeply into all of the Actions, Amendments, cited art, and other documents in the file history—perhaps thousands of pages. We figured out where previous arguments had gone wrong and determined how we could overcome them after the invention had received so many rejections. We explored the technical issues in depth.
Through a process of deconstruction—breaking each objection into its individual elements and then arguing against each of those components—we were able to prevail upon the Examiners to allow in turn each application.